Home > Parent Perspective, Science & Research, Vaccine Myths > Not Every Parent of an Autistic Child Believes Vaccines Are To Blame

Not Every Parent of an Autistic Child Believes Vaccines Are To Blame

By Christine Vara

Not having an autistic child myself, I admit that I have no idea of the never ending challenges that parents with autistic children face on a day to day basis.  I think about all the physical and emotional energy it takes for me to raise my children, and I know that it can never compare to that of a parent raising an autistic child. Even though I know many people raising autistic children, without walking in their shoes, I can’t fully understand their daily concerns.  How presumptuous it would be if I ever thought I could. 

So, I wonder, how do parents of autistic children feel when someone presumes that they blame vaccines for their child’s autism?

Of course, each individual is coming from a different perspective on the issue of vaccines and autism.   I would suspect that for all the things that parents of autistic children have in common, their opinions on vaccines are equally as diverse.  Yet this difference of opinion is representative of all parents, not just those with autistic children.  One of the reasons I feel so strongly about contributing to this blog is because I believe the average parent is just not that well educated on the science behind vaccines.  However, most parents will readily acknowledge that they’ve “heard” the suggestion that vaccines are somehow linked to autism. 

For those of us who recognize the benefits of vaccines, this is an unfortunate reality.  On the one hand you have parents who refer to the experts (scientists, doctors and public health officials) for guidance in regards to vaccines.  Then, on the other hand, you have parents who are emotionally attached to the personal stories they hear from parents of autistic children who believe their child’s autism has been brought on by vaccines.  Then there is a whole lot of uncertainty and confusion that lies in between.

Personally, I believe it speaks volumes when the parents of autistic children publicly acknowledge their respect for the scientific process and the validity of the research that has been done.  One woman in particular, who is committed to autism research and awareness, is Alison Singer.  As the founder of The Autism Science Foundation, Alison is an enormous asset to the autism community.   

In their most recent blog post, The Autism Science Foundation strongly supported the findings of the recent Pediatrics article  that indicated that thimerosal-containing vaccines are not linked to Autism Spectrum Disorders.  Dr. Sharon Humiston, a pediatrician and FAAP, former member of the National Vaccine Advisory Committee (NVAC) and member of the Autism Science Foundation Science Advisory Board, is quoted as saying,

“In a way, it’d be great if thimerosal in infant vaccines was the culprit because the U.S. has already removed thimerosal from them.  Because we have not found the root causes of autism, we need to keep funding the research that will help us find them.  Because the resources to find what really does cause autism are scarce – money, scientists, and time – we urgently need to focus these resources on avenues that appear to be fruitful.  The vaccine hypothesis just has not yielded answers that help my autistic son or my typically developing daughter who may want to have children of her own one day.”

Other autism parents have weighed in on this as well.  Another blog post by Emily Willingham, a scientist and autism parent, has also analyzed the recent Pediatrics study, addressing the criticism that often circulates regarding conflicts of interest and conspiracy.

It is clear from these responses that there are autistic parents who accept the evidence that thimerosal exposure does not cause autism.  Yet, in reading the blog piece from Left Brain, Right Brain, that also covered the Pediatrics study in detail, I came across a reader comment that went so far as to suggest that all autism is caused by vaccines.  I wondered how that comment would resonate within the autism community.  (This reader even offering up a “reward” for anyone who could produce an unvaccinated autistic child – as if none exist.)   

As author of a recent LA Times article, “Once more, no link found between vaccine preservative and autism”, Melissa Healey highlights that the recent Pediatrics findings are just the latest in a long line of research.  She questions whether “Study Number 10” will provide sufficient evidence to put this hypothesis to rest. 

As a parent, I consider the Pediatrics findings relevant since they not only support, but also elaborate upon, previous scientific findings.  Additionally, since Pediatrics is a peer–reviewed journal and the official journal of the America Academy of Pediatrics, this report will hopefully provide pediatricians with more evidence to reference when discussing parental concerns related to vaccines.  Perhaps, as parents are repeatedly exposed to these recurring findings, they will begin to understand a new message that thimerosal-containing vaccines are not linked to autism.    

While I will remain hopefull, I’m not making any presumptions.

  1. Poogles
    September 15, 2010 at 5:33 pm

    “I came across a reader comment that went so far as to suggest that all autism is caused by vaccines. I wondered how that comment would resonate within the autism community. (This reader even offering up a “reward” for anyone who could produce an unvaccinated autistic child – as if none exist.) ”

    Looks like Mr Bateson :-/

    He makes the rounds on articles/posts on vaccines or autism and makes the same claim over and over. People have provided him with numerous examples of un-vaccinated autistic individuals and he ignores them and continues to post his “challenge” all over the internet.

    Like

  2. September 15, 2010 at 6:26 pm

    Looks like the internet ate my comment, dang it, maybe because I had so many links. I’ll try again sans links. You can search for the bloggers I mention and their blogs should show up.

    There are a number of parents of children with autism who reject the “vaccines cause autism” meme, in addition to Kev Leitch & Sullivan (LeftBrain/RightBrain) and Emily Willingham. There may in fact be more parents who reject the vaccine causation meme than accept it. The difficulty is that those parents — call them the science-based parents or the evidence-accepting parents — don’t go to rallies and don’t organize over the issue.

    Kristina Chew and Shannon des Roches Rosa are two parents who spring to mind, both of whom have boys with significant challenges from autism. Kim Wombles has several children on the spectrum. Ken Reibel of Autism News Beat was featured in the Penn & Teller anti-anti-vaccination episode.

    If you look through the Autism Blogs Directory, you will find a number more adults with autism and parents of children with autism.

    Like

  3. autismsciencefoundation
    September 15, 2010 at 9:40 pm

    We linked to this story on the ASF Facebook page and there are some great comments. Please visit: http://www.facebook.com/?ref=logo#!/pages/Autism-Science-Foundation/150494705660?ref=ts

    Like

  4. ann
    September 18, 2010 at 7:57 am

    I don’t know what causes autism, but I do know that the more developed countries have 1 out of every100 or so child being diagnosed with autism and the underdeveloped countries do not.

    I don’t know why if only 1 in 40 million die from chicken pox, why you would need a vaccine for it. I don’t know what causes autism , but I think 20+ vaccines in the first 2 years of life in a little body is alot. I’m not againest vaccines, look how they have helped, but I am about asking questions, like “what are all the ingredients inthat vaccine you are going to put in my baby’s leg” DNA from an animal, some of the ingredients I just don’t like, nor the way they culture it, in the lung of an aborted baby from the 1970’s, it’s published material,not hard to find, everyone seems to trust those in white coats, I like to ask questions first and think.

    Like

  5. September 19, 2010 at 9:45 pm

    There are evidence-based responses to all of your assertions out there on the interwebz. They’ve been debunked.

    Like

  6. Roger Kulp
    September 21, 2010 at 10:39 pm

    Death is not always the only permanent result of diseases like chicken pox.
    The antivaxers like to talk bout how sick their “vaccine damaged children” are.Many children who have an autism diagnosis really are sick.Metabolic disease,PANDAS,and many other problems.These are children,who while they may not die,have a genetic predisposition to develop serious autoimmune conditions from “harmless” childhood infections.Diseases now preventable by vaccines.I know,I was such a child.

    Let’s take chicken pox,a virus the antivax crowd likes to say is perfectly harmless.In a succeptable child,this can result in

    hemolytic anemia

    autoimmune hepatitis

    Autoimmune protein S deficiency

    Pediatric Myasthenia Gravis

    Encephalitis

    cerebral vasculitis

    shingles in older children

    And more.

    Oh,and I would like like to know where you read that vaccines,varicella or others are “cultured in the lung of an aborted baby from the 1970s”.

    Document,and source that

    Like

  7. Ross Coe
    March 7, 2011 at 2:41 am

    So some parents don’t believe, so what? Thats just their ignorance showing.

    Like

  8. Giovanni Tucci
    February 3, 2013 at 2:29 pm

    infections diseases should be treated as early as possible to prevent outbreaks and also to reduce the damage to the body…

    Our personal webpage
    <i="http://www.healthmedicinecentral.com/pulled-neck-muscle/

    Like

  9. Chris
    February 3, 2013 at 8:08 pm

    Again, you are spamming that webpage. And you must be very bad at it, since it does not exist.

    Like

  10. July 28, 2013 at 9:40 am

    Unquestionably believe that which you said.
    Your favorite justification seemed to be on the web the easiest thing to be aware of.
    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly do not know about.

    You managed to hit the nail upon the top as well as defined
    out the whole thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal.
    Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

    Like

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s