The Controversy over Dr. Oz
Apr 09, 2010

By Christine Vara
I have just read a very insightful article from the Chicago Tribune regarding Dr. Oz and his proliferation of medical information on both his current television show and the website that supports it.  The article leads with the header, “Celebrity surgeon’s goal is to offer ‘as much information as possible’ on health issues. But critics say that inclusive approach does the public a disservice.” 
As a brief overview, Dr. Oz is a cardiac surgeon who was a regular guest on “The Oprah Winfrey Show” before becoming a celebrity himself.  The Chicago Tribune article brings to light several instances where claims made through the site are not supported by medical science.  Dr. Oz’s spokespeople explain that to offer a fair discussion, they must include various voices and even controversial opinions. 
While I can certainly appreciate an open dialogue, it seems that in the interest of “entertainment” this celebrity doctor walks a fine line between the opinions of a few with the evidence of scientific research.  By the simple nature of him being a doctor himself, people will listen, which accounts for the 3.7 million viewers to his show daily.  However, the concerns I have are not with the sharing or discussing of information, or even the questioning of current medical beliefs.  It remains important to medical advancement that we use this kind of dialogue to direct us in further research to prove various hypotheses.  My concerns are that when mass media starts involving the lay people in this medical conversation, it is easy for many of us to confuse suggestion of evidence with proven research.  
Dr. Oz’s website includes small print that clarifies that his website is for “information and entertainment purposes only”.  However, I feel that it can be misleading to have information that is not substantiated by scientific evidence used for entertainment purposes.   The disservice comes when the medical profession puts celebrity status and sensational media tactics above their duty to serve the public well being.  Please read the Chicago Tribune article and let me know your thoughts.


Related Posts

This guest post was written by Alethea Mshar out of concern for her son Ben.  A version of this post originally appeared on her blog Ben’s Writing, Running Mom. Like all parents, my child’s health...

I could hear it clearly from across the auditorium.  A distinctive cough in a very small child.  It was painful to my ears and I brought a sinking feeling to my heart.  My daughter glanced over...


0 responses to “The Controversy over Dr. Oz”

  1. Dr. Oz is an entertainer who happens to be a physician. That’s all. His show is entertaining. That’s all.

  2. […] Today’s post will be focusing on another major source of health news- television. Specifically, none other than Dr. Oz. The confident celebrity physician who hosts The Dr. Oz Show frequently promotes the healthy lifestyle choices and what he shares frequently becomes the next hot topic in health, at least among the everyday person.  Targeting his main audience, middle-age women, he often promotes foods and methods of weight loss. When Dr. Oz mentions an amazing health supplement that makes weight loss “easy”, you can bet his 3.7 million viewers are listening (according to here). […]

  3. The Weight Tracker simplifies weight data logging, so women can add multiple records per day, and develop
    a summary of the logs through a graph. There are however, a great many women who believe that contractions started within hours
    of eating a particularly spicy meal. This can lead to damage to the
    genitals of both male and female dogs.

  4. Verona says:

    But should you prefer richer taste of drinks, then
    vacuum type machine or manual type machine can be
    a better choice. These days it can be not uncommon to
    get people owning a coffee brewer. Coffee is something that’s
    enjoyed by everyone as it has the quality to awaken your senses
    and make you feel refreshed.

  5. Julian says:

    In this way, the hydroxyl radical is sort of nature’s
    atmospheric “scrubbing bubbles. Now after shoveling snow and exposing my face to the elements that had me sold at the gate. HEPA is an abbreviation to describe a ‘High Efficiency Particulate Arresting’ filter, originally designed in the 1940s by the US military to prevent the spread of airborne radioactive particles.

  6. Scarlett says:

    Upright cleaners are heavy and powerful, and sometimes
    not as manoeuvrable as canisters. Think about the items that are
    going to be cleaned and read reviews of different products to
    determine which is best for you. Before you purchase, though,
    always make sure that these universal tools will work with the
    cleaner you have at home.

  7. Lorri says:

    VHS Tapes ‘ Some Non-profit organizations are providing work to disabled people by collecting your
    old tapes and erasing them for re-using the good ones and recycling the old, cleaned plastic
    tapes. Insert the free HP Photo Editor available to download
    here which makes it really easy to upload your logos, images, and photos.
    One way of accessorizing a plain wall is by placing a
    large mirror that reflects all your bright decorations.

  8. You need to combine practicality and personal touch in the gifts.
    Find out more by shopping on the web at your leisure and
    in order to compare and contrast the different prices.
    Adult comfort – It is all well and good to
    have your baby comfortable, but if your back carrier
    is not comfortable then you will not be going far (or you will only be doing it once.

  9. A few years ago, my husband and I decided that we’d make our Christmas
    gifts. With just few days remaining before Christmas, you might already
    be worried on thinking about the best gift you can give your husband.
    If it’s the thrill of opening up the presents that excites you most about
    Christmas then what do you do later on the day when everything has been unwrapped and
    the Christmas dinner has become a messy pile of washing up.

  10. Many blenders will not work unless the blades are stuck place.
    This ultimate package Kitchen – Aid Hand Blender also also comes in white,
    empire red and onyx black. Some of those blenders come with separate containers, while other variants do
    not.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *